All methods

COPRAS

Available

COmplex PRoportional ASsessment. Zavadskas et al. (1994)

The idea

Benefit share plus a bonus for low cost
A40.1702100.00%A70.162395.38%A60.161594.92%A50.137780.90%A20.134078.72%A30.120670.87%A10.113766.82%

Each bar is S+ (benefit share) plus the cost bonus, which grows as the cost share S- shrinks; it ends at Q, then N in percent of the best.

  • Benefit share S+
  • Cost bonus
Show as table
AlternativeBenefit share S+Cost bonusRelative significance QUtility degree N (%)
A40.08830.08190.1702100.00%
A70.08120.08110.162395.38%
A60.10320.05840.161594.92%
A50.07890.05880.137780.90%
A20.05300.08100.134078.72%
A30.05870.06190.120670.87%
A10.03180.08190.113766.82%

Data: Cream separators (Özcan and Çelik 2021).

COPRAS adds up each alternative's weighted benefit shares, adds a bonus that grows as its cost share shrinks, and shows every alternative as a percentage of the best.

When to use it

  • Every value is a positive amount: prices, durations, counts.
  • Benefit and cost criteria are mixed.
  • Costs should stay in their own term, not flipped first.

Algorithm

  1. 1Weighted shares of the column total

    Benefit and cost columns alike; nothing is inverted.

  2. 2Benefit and cost sums
  3. 3Relative significance

    With no cost criteria, or cost weights that are all 0, Q equals S+ (SAW with the sum option).

  4. 4Utility degree

    Rank by decreasing Q; the best alternative has N = 100 %.

Used together with

Why these pairs
  • Entropy weights, then COPRAS: Özcan & Çelik (2021), the example used here.
  • AHP weights, then COPRAS (Aytaç Adalı & Tuş Işık 2016); the 2007 restatement uses expert weights.
  • SWARA and COPRAS co-occur in 154 OpenAlex records, more than SWARA and TOPSIS.
  • With at most one cost criterion COPRAS gives exactly SAW with the sum option; they differ from two cost criteria on.

Reference example

Özcan, S.; Çelik, A.K. (2021)Matches the printed digits
Details

Özcan, S.; Çelik, A.K. (2021). A comparison of TOPSIS, grey relational analysis and COPRAS methods for machine selection problem in the food industry of Turkey. International Journal of Production Management and Engineering 9(2), 81-92. doi:10.4995/ijpme.2021.14734

Published example, reproduced by the tests: seven cream separators, seven criteria (four of them cost), Entropy weights (Tables 1, 2, 10, 11). All 49 cells of Table 10 match to 4 decimals and the seven Q values of Table 11 to 0.0001; our Entropy reproduces the weights of Table 2. The printed rank row swaps A2 and A3 (it copies the TOPSIS column); the ranks here follow the printed Q. Also tested: Podvezko (2011, Tables 7-8), and Zavadskas et al. (2007), whose Table 2 prints Q = S+ + S- instead of its own Eq. 5, so only its S+ and S- are used.

Checked by this site's test suite.

Sources

Show 7 sources
  1. Zavadskas et al. (1994). The new method of multicriteria complex proportional assessment of projects. Technological and Economic Development of Economy 1(3), 131-139. The origin the authors cite themselves; no DOI and no copy online, so it was not opened. The formulas follow their own restatement (Zavadskas, Kaklauskas, Peldschus & Turskis 2007, Eqs. 1-6), checked against Podvezko (2011).
  2. Zavadskas, Kaklauskas & Šarka (1994), Technological and Economic Development of Economy 1(3), 131-139 (not opened)
  3. Zavadskas, Kaklauskas, Peldschus & Turskis (2007), Multi-attribute assessment of road design solutions by using the COPRAS method, The Baltic Journal of Road and Bridge Engineering 2(4), 195-203
  4. Podvezko (2011), The Comparative Analysis of MCDA Methods SAW and COPRAS, Engineering Economics 22(2), 134-146 doi:10.5755/j01.ee.22.2.310
  5. Özcan & Çelik (2021), International Journal of Production Management and Engineering 9(2), 81-92 doi:10.4995/ijpme.2021.14734
  6. Keshavarz Ghorabaee, Zavadskas, Olfat & Turskis (2015), Informatica 26(3), 435-451 doi:10.15388/Informatica.2015.57
  7. pyDecision 5.1.1, copras_method (returns only N / 100) github.com/Valdecy/pyDecision