All methods

PROMETHEE II

Available

Preference Ranking Organization METHod for Enrichment of Evaluations II. Brans et al. (1986)

The idea

Leaving flow, entering flow, and net outranking flow
Model 4+0.5591Model 3+0.1834Model 5+0.1713Model 2-0.1002Model 6-0.3562Model 1-0.4574

PROMETHEE I incomparable pairs: Model 1 ↔ Model 6

Each laptop model is compared pair by pair across criteria: leaving flow φ⁺ (how much it beats others) minus entering flow φ⁻ (how much others beat it) gives the net flow φ.

Show as table
Alternativeφ⁺φ⁻φ
Model 40.60930.0503+0.5591
Model 30.26870.0853+0.1834
Model 50.26060.0893+0.1713
Model 20.12190.2220-0.1002
Model 60.03650.3928-0.3562
Model 10.04150.4989-0.4574

Data: Laptop selection (Goswami 2020).

PROMETHEE compares alternatives pair by pair on each criterion with a chosen preference function and ranks them by net flow.

When to use it

  • You can name negligible (q) and decisive (p) differences.
  • Very different scales, and no normalization should decide their spread.
  • You want PROMETHEE I to expose incomparable pairs.

Algorithm

  1. 1Pairwise differences

    Only differences are used, so there is no normalization step and negative values are fine.

  2. 2Preference function per criterion

    Six types: I usual (any difference counts), II U-shape (q), III V-shape (p), IV level (q, p), V linear with indifference (q, p), VI Gaussian (s).

  3. 3Example: type V, linear with indifference

    Differences up to q are ignored, differences above p count fully, and preference grows linearly in between.

  4. 4Aggregated preference index
  5. 5Leaving and entering flows

    m is the number of alternatives; the 1986 paper reports plain sums without 1/(m-1), which gives the same ranking.

  6. 6Net flow

    PROMETHEE II ranks by decreasing net flow, while PROMETHEE I uses the two flows separately and shows pairs where they disagree as incomparable.

Used together with

Why these pairs
  • AHP then PROMETHEE (1,484 OpenAlex co-mentions): Dağdeviren (2008), equipment selection. The first AHP-PROMETHEE paper is dated 1995 by Çebi et al. (2022).
  • Fuzzy ANP or fuzzy AHP then PROMETHEE: Tuzkaya et al. (2010), material handling equipment.
  • Entropy or CRITIC then PROMETHEE is common, but PROMETHEE does not normalize: weights computed on a normalized matrix and thresholds in raw units describe different things.
  • As a cross-check next to TOPSIS, VIKOR and COPRAS: Sałabun, Wątróbski & Shekhovtsov (2020).

Reference example

Brans, J.-P.; Vincke, Ph.; Mareschal, B. (1986)Matches the printed digits
Details

Brans, J.-P.; Vincke, Ph.; Mareschal, B. (1986). How to select and how to rank projects: The PROMETHEE method. European Journal of Operational Research 24(2), 228-238. doi:10.1016/0377-2217(86)90044-5

Tested against the published hydroelectric power station example (six projects, six criteria, one preference type per criterion; input in Mareschal 2019, Table 1) and the Goswami (2020) laptop selection problem (Tables 13-18). The ranking a5 > a2 > a4 > a6 > a3 > a1 matches; pi differs by at most 0.001 and the summed net flow by 0.002 because the 1986 table rounds pi to 3 decimals before summing. Goswami (2020) matches to 0.00001, and pyDecision agrees to 1e-16.

Checked by this site's test suite.

Sources

Show 11 sources
  1. Brans et al. (1986). How to select and how to rank projects: The PROMETHEE method. European Journal of Operational Research 24(2), 228-238. doi:10.1016/0377-2217(86)90044-5First presented by Brans in 1982 (Université Laval). Companion paper: Brans & Vincke (1985), Management Science 31(6), 647-656.
  2. Brans, Vincke & Mareschal (1986), European Journal of Operational Research 24(2), 228-238 doi:10.1016/0377-2217(86)90044-5
  3. Brans & Vincke (1985), Management Science 31(6), 647-656 doi:10.1287/mnsc.31.6.647
  4. Brans & Mareschal (2005), PROMETHEE methods doi:10.1007/0-387-23081-5_5
  5. Mareschal (2015), Note on the PROMETHEE net flow computation bertrand.mareschal.web.ulb.be/PG2024/assets/promethee_net_flow.pdf
  6. Mareschal (2019), Exercises with Visual PROMETHEE bertrand.mareschal.web.ulb.be/PG2024/assets/exercises-vp-2019.pdf
  7. Goswami (2020), Foundations of Management 12(1), 93-110 doi:10.2478/fman-2020-0008
  8. Behzadian et al. (2010), 217 PROMETHEE papers reviewed, EJOR 200(1), 198-215 doi:10.1016/j.ejor.2009.01.021
  9. De Keyser & Peeters (1996), EJOR 89, 457-461 doi:10.1016/0377-2217(94)00307-6
  10. Verly & De Smet (2013), IJMCDM 3(4), 325-345 doi:10.1504/IJMCDM.2013.056781
  11. Sałabun, Wątróbski & Shekhovtsov (2020), Symmetry 12(9), 1549 doi:10.3390/sym12091549